To finish out my little curriculum, I’m bringing you one of my absolute favourite horror tropes: uncanny architecture. From staircases that don’t go where they should to walls that can’t possibly contain their contents, from haunted houses to hair-raising hotels, there’s nothing that turns the mundane into the nightmarish like a floorplan that just isn’t quite right (or worse).
Primary reading:
House of Leaves by Mark Danielewski – It’s not only the architecture of the house in House of Leaves that is unsettling, it’s the architecture of the book itself. Nothing I say will help you know whether you should read it as much as just getting your hands on a copy and flipping it open to any page to decide for yourself. It’s not the scariest book I’ve ever read, but it’s the only one that has ever given me a nightmare.
Hereditary (dir. Ari Aster) – I went back and forth so many times on whether to include this in Unit 3 or Unit 4. It is an incredible example of grief permeating a horror story, and many would call it the pinnacle of modern grief horror. But to me, it’s the way a domestic space transforms from safe to insecure, from comfortable to claustrophobic, from known to, yes, uncanny, that makes Hereditary truly terrifying. The house itself isn’t haunted, but everyone in it is. Warning for fraidy cats: this is not one I’d recommend for horror newbies.
The Shining (dir. Stanley Kubrick) – Stanley Kubrick was a famously detail-oriented perfectionist and the unsettling nature of The Overlook’s architecture is no accident. The hotel may look normal at first, but if a hallway doesn’t lead to where it ought to, or if a room seems bigger than it should, that’s all by design. And then there’s the enormous, sprawling hedge maze outside. It might be enough to drive someone mad.
The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson – Like Hereditary, Jackson’s classic novel could also fit nicely into the grief unit (which is why Flanagan’s adaption is there), but the architecture of the house is a key element of knocking its inhabitants off-kilter. Sure, stairs that aren’t quite level and angles that aren’t quite 90 degrees are hallmarks of any old house, but there’s a lack of logic throughout the descriptions in the novel that will have you wracking your brains trying to make sense of the floorplan.
Secondary reading:
Piranesi by Susanna Clarke – This novel takes the form of a journal, documenting the protagonist’s exploration of an impossible space of infinite halls, staircases, and vestibules. I’m putting this novel under “secondary” reading because the world that Piranesi explores isn’t really meant to resemble a familiar place, even if the protagonist feels like it is (for a while, anyway). But it’s one of my favourite novels and a perfect example of the impossible architecture in literature, so I highly recommend it.
Backrooms (dir. Kane Parsons) – To be honest, I didn’t love Backrooms, although I appreciated what it was trying to do. But I do think its depiction of an endless array of rooms and hallways — all dressed up in the bland banality of an abandoned office — has an incredible uncanniness. There are plenty of less mainstream examples of liminal space you could seek out, but this is an easy one to explore if you’re curious about dipping your toes in.
The City & The City by China Miéville – In Miéville’s speculative fiction novel, the architecture itself isn’t necessarily strange, but the way the characters must react to it is. It is set in two cities that overlap, and the residents of one city must not acknowledge the existence of the other, not its buildings or its people. What could be more uncanny than having to un-know what you see in front of you?
Doctor Who – If the House of Leaves or the Backrooms feel too spooky to explore, here’s one example of impossible architecture that is designed to surprise, but not scare. Is it uncanny? Well, a phone booth is a pretty normal object (or at least it was in the pre-mobile phone age). If you’re somehow not familiar with Doctor Who’s TARDIS, here’s a supercut of its visitors realising that “it’s bigger on the inside.”
